Seasonal Sarah's Menu
Pies
Apple Crisp
Signature Pie Crust with Apple Pie Filling and Oat Crisp Topping.
$31
Apple Pecan Crumble
Signature Pie Crust with Apple Pie Filling and Pecan Crumb Topping.
$32
Apple Pie
Signature Pie Crust with Apple Pie Filling
$30
★ Appleberry Rhubarb Pie
Signature Pie Crust with Apple, Strawberry, Rhubarb, & Cherry Filling
$33
★ Apricots & Cream Pie
Browned Butter Oatmeal Cookie Crust with Fresh Apricot Buttermilk filling and a Homemade Apricot Jelly and Cream topping.
$50
Bailey's Cheesecake
Cheesecake with Bailey's Irish Cream and a Java Chip Cookie Crust
$34
Banana Cream Pie
Vanilla Wafer Cookie Crust
$30
Banoffee Pie
Banana Toffee
$32
★ Berry Custard Lemon Thyme Crumb
$30
Birthday Cake Pie
$30
★ Blackberry Crisp
$32
★ Black Cobbler
Blackberries & Black Raspberries
$32
Black & Blue Crumb
Blackberries & Blueberries
$32
Black Bottom Pie
$30
★ Black Forest Pie
$34
Black Raspberry Cheesecake
$34
★ Blackberry Pie
$30
★ Blood Orange Meringue Pie
$35
Blueberry Pie
Signature Pie Crust with Blueberry Pie Filling
$30
Blueberry Lavender Hand Pie
*Minimum of 6 per order
$6
Blueberry Lavendar Pie
$32
Blueberry Mascarpone Pie
$30
★ Blueberry Rhuby Rose Pie
Signature Pie Crust with Blueberries, Rhubarb, and a touch of Rosewater
$32
Blue Razz Granola Pie
$32
Boston Cream Pie
$30
★ Boysenberry Pie
$45
★ Bumbleberry Pie with Lavendar Crumb
$32
★ Brown Butter Chestnut Pie
$32
Brown Butter Maple Chess Pie
$30
★ Bumbleberry Pie
$30
Butterfinger Pie
$30
Butter Pecan Pie
$32
Butterscotch Pie
$30
★ Cadbury Creme Pie
$30
★ Cheesecake with Concord Grape
$35
★ Cherry Pie
$35
★ Cherry Rhubarb Pie
$32
★ Chocolate Covered Strawberry Pie
$32
Chocolate Cream Pie
$30
Chocolate Hazelnut Pie
$30
Coconut Cream Pie
$30
Coconut Custard Pie
$30
Coffee & Cream Pie
$30
Cookie Butter Pie
$32
★ Cranberry Cobbler
$30
Dutch Apple Caramel
Signature Pie Crust with Apple Pie Filling, Crumb Topping, and Caramel drizzle
$32
★ Fig Galette
$36
Fruit Tart
$40
★ Gingerbread Pie
$32
Gluten Free Pie
$35
★ Goldilocks Pie
Signature Pie Crust with Golden Filling: Golden Delicious Apples, Goldenberries, Golden Plums, and Golden Cayenne Pepper
$32
Grasshopper Pie
Frozen Mint Custard with Mint Chocolate Cookie Crust
$30
Guava Pie
$30
★ Honeysuckle Creme Brulee
$32
★ Huckleberry Pie
$50
Irish Cream Mud Pie
$32
Key Lime Pie
$30
★ Lady Liberty Pie
Signature Pie Crust with Red Raspberries, White Peaches, and Blueberries
$32
★ Lavendar Love Pie
Signature Pie Crust with Strawberries, Cherries, White Peaches, Apples, and Lavender
$32
Lemon Basil Pie
$30
Lemon Chiffon Pie
$30
Lemon Crisp
$30
Lemon Ice Box Pie
$30
Lemon Pie w/ Meringue Cookies
$30
Mango Pie with Meringue
$32
★ May the 4th be with you pie / Light Side Dark Side
$32
Mississippi Mud Pie
$30
Mixed Berry Pie
Signature Pie Crust with Strawberries, Raspberries, and Blueberries
$32
★ NJ Peach Pie
Signature Pie Crust with both Yellow and White Peaches and a touch of Vanilla
$32
Orange Creamsicle Ice Cream Pie
$30
Peanut Butter Pie
$30
Pear & Blood Orange Pie
$32
★ Pear & Cranberry Pie
$32
Pecan Pie
Signature Pie Crust w/ Pecan Pie Filling
$30
Pineapple Pie
$30
Pink Lemonade Pie
$30
Pistachio Buttermilk Chess Pie
$30
Pistachio Pudding Pie
$30
★ Pumpkin Pie
Signature Pie Crust w/ Pumpkin Pie Filling
$30
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Pie
$30
★ Pumpkin Swirl Cheesecake
Pumpkin Cheesecake w/ a Gingersnap cookie crust
$30
★ Purple Berry Pie
Blueberries, Black Raspberries, & Lavendar
$32
★ Purple Sweet Potato Pie
Signature Pie Crust w/ Purple Sweet Potato Pie Filling
$32
Quiche
$35
Raspberry Pie
$33
Red Bean and Green Tea Ice Cream Pie
$30
Red Velvet Pie
$35
Rye Pie
Apples, Pears, & Lemon, w/ Rye Whiskey
$30
Shoofly Pie
$30
★ *Seasonal Sarah's Signature Pie
Apricot, Plum, & White Peach
$32
Smores Pie
$30
Snickerdoodle Pie
Snickerdoodle Cookie Crust w/ a Cinnamon Custard topped w/ Cinnamon Sugar
$30
Snickers Pie
$30
★ Sour Cherry Almond Crisp
$33
★ Sour Cherry Pie
$32
Strawberry Cream Cheese Pie
$30
★ Strawberry Rhubarb Crisp
$32
★ Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
$32
Strawberry Lemonade Pie
$30
Sunflower Pie
$30
Texas Flood Pie
$30
Toasted Almond Custard Pie
$30
★ Tomato Corn Pie
$30
Tuxedo Pie
$30
Winter Blueberry Pie
Blueberry Pie w/ freshly grated nutmeg and cinnamon streusel topping
$32
Zucchini Cobbler
$30
Specialty Pies
Gluten Free Pie
$35
Vegan Pie
$35
Sugar Free Pie
Please let us know if Honey is acceptable in place of any sugar? Or any other special request of sweetner. We can also leave it out completely.
$35
Spice Mixes
Pie Spices
Apple Pie Spice, Pumpkin Pie Spice, Chai Spice
$25
Cookies
Assortment
$65
Brown Butter Matcha Cookies
$40
Christmas Tree Star Cookies
$40
Danish Butter Cookies
$40
French Vanilla Cookies
$40
Gingerbread Cookies
$40
Pignoli Cookies
$40
Pistachio Cookies
$40
Snickerdoodle Cookies
$40
Popcorns
Gingerbread Popcorn
$20
Cakes, Breads, & Buns
Bread Pudding
$28
★ Carrot Cake Roll
$35
★ Cranberry Cupcakes
1 dozen
$40
★ Easter Bread
$10
★ French Vanilla Cupcakes with Guava Filling and Honeysuckle Icing
$45
★ Irish Soda Bread
$7
★ Lemon Lavendar Cupcakes with Wildflower Honey Icing
$45
Norwegian Strawberry Nut Bread
$25
Pecan Sticky Buns
$36
Petite Fours
$50
Strawberry Rolls
$40
Yule Log Cake
$50
Ice Cream
★ Black Raspberry Ice Cream
$10
★ Corn Ice Cream
Great on Blueberry Pie!
$10
Gingerbread Ice Cream Sundae
$10
Jams, Jellies, & Butters
★ Cherry Tomato Jelly
$8.50
Hot Pepper Jelly
$8.50
★ Pineapple Rhubarb Jam
$8.50
★ Rhubarb Butter
$9
★ Strawberry Jam
$8.50
Sauces
★ Blueberry BBQ Sauce
$15
Lemon Drop Hot Sauce
$20
Mints & Candies
Lavender Butter Mints
$5
GOURMET CRUST
Upgrade to Gourmet Pie Crust
(Price Per Pie) Upgraded crust includes the following ingredients: - Lard - Pure Irish Grass Fed Butter - Golden Sugar - Pastry Flour - Honeysuckle Vodka
$6
Pie Sodas
Blackberry Pie Soda
$5.50
Boysenberry Pie Soda
$5.50
Cherries and Cream Pie Soda
$5.50
Key Lime Pie Soda
$5.50
Lemon Meringue Pie Soda
$5.50
Peaches and Cream Pie Soda
$5.50
